Lopez v. Smith, 574 U.S. 1 (decided October 6, 2014): Court grants cert and upholds state murder conviction where prosecution switched theories at end of trial (defendant aided and abetted murder of wife instead of directly wielding metal bar that killed her); Ninth Circuit had relied on its own precedent, which prohibited such practices, in granting habeas, but 1996 statute restricting habeas only to where state court misapplied federal law refers only to federal law established by the Court (which has been silent on this issue) (this strikes me as odd; Thomas, who wrote the opinion, seems to be saying only SCOTUS can declare federal law — but if a federal law issue is totally settled and universally accepted, it might never have gotten considered by SCOTUS because no one bothered to litigate it, or there never was a split of authority for the Court to resolve)
top of page
Recent Posts
See AllRhode Island v. Innis, 446 U.S. 291 (decided May 12, 1980): Armed robbery defendant, after being given Miranda warnings and riding in police car, should have been given additional Miranda warning befo
Smith v. Texas, 233 U.S. 630 (decided May 11, 1914): Texas statute restricting employment as a conductor to those who have already been conductors or brakemen for two years violates equal protection b
Yick Wo v. Hopkins, 118 U.S. 356 (decided May 10, 1886): Fourteenth Amendment violated by ordinance allowing denial without recourse of permits to laundries in wooden buildings; effect was to discrimi
bottom of page