top of page
Today in Supreme Court History
with Dan Schiavetta, Jr.
a.k.a. “captcrisis”
Today in Supreme Court History: November 21
New York, New Haven & Hartford R.R. Co. v. Henagan, 364 U.S. 441 (decided November 21, 1960): Woman attemped suicide by stepping in front of train; train came to sudden stop and waitress in dining car injured by the jolt (soft tissue injuries and “paranoid psychosis”). Court affirms judgment for the railroad. (P.S. Train did not stop in time.) State of Washington v. Kuykendall, 275 U.S. 207 (decided November 21, 1927): towing of logs across Puget Sound met statutory defini

captcrisis
2 minutes ago1 min read
Today in Supreme Court History: November 20
Osborne v. County of Adams, 106 U.S. 181 (decided November 20, 1882): a steam grist mill is not an “internal improvement” under state statute authorizing county to issue bonds for construction; statute deals only with railroads and related structures (not clear why there’s federal court jurisdiction here; the lower court seemed to say there wasn’t, yet decided the merits anyway, 7 F. 441) O’Neil v. Northern Colorado Irrigation Co., 242 U.S. 20 (decided November 20, 1916): far

captcrisis
18 hours ago1 min read
Today in Supreme Court History: November 19
Goudy v. Meath, 203 U.S. 146 (decided November 19, 1906): Congress may exempt land held by Native Americans from taxation before they sell it but didn’t do so here; Congress had declared in 1887 that plaintiff’s tribe were now citizens so he had to pay taxes from that point forward United States v. Cambridge Loan & Building Co., 278 U.S. 55 (decided November 19, 1928): government was estopped from collecting back taxes despite taxpayer “building and loan association” making t

captcrisis
2 days ago1 min read
Today in Supreme Court History: November 18
Ohio v. Robinette, 519 U.S. 33 (decided November 18, 1996): search of car was truly consensual even though police officer didn’t first tell driver he was “free to go” (police asked to search, driver said yes, and drugs were found) Pennsylvania Bureau of Correction v. United States Marshals Service, 474 U.S. 34 (decided November 18, 1985): habeas statute does not allow federal judge to order marshals to bring state prisoners to the courthouse as witnesses; must be by subpoena

captcrisis
3 days ago1 min read
Today in Supreme Court History: November 17
Dennis v. Sparks, 449 U.S. 24 (decided November 17, 1980): private parties who allegedly corruptly conspired with judge to deny oil lease in violation of Due Process can still be sued under §1983 even though co-conspirator judge enjoys judicial immunity (echoes of the Watergate convictions, with Nixon as an unindicted co-conspirator) Crouch v. United States, 266 U.S. 180 (decided November 17, 1924): war widow (husband had been on The Cyclops, which disappeared at sea in March

captcrisis
4 days ago1 min read
Today in Supreme Court History: November 16
Louisville & Nashville R.R. Co. v. Mottley, 211 U.S. 149 (decided November 16, 1908): defendant’s assertion of defenses based on federal law does not create federal court jurisdiction (I remember this one from law school; a couple guaranteed lifetime passage on a railroad as consideration for settling a personal injury case sued 35 years later when their tickets were no longer being honored) Hardy v. Harbin, 154 U.S. 598 (decided November 16, 1874): Was John Hardy the same as

captcrisis
5 days ago1 min read
Today in Supreme Court History: November 15
The Harrisburg, 119 U.S. 199 (decided November 15, 1886): can’t sue in admiralty for wrongful death because Congress has not provided for it (overruled by Moragne v. States Marine Lines, 1970) Moody v. Daggett, 429 U.S. 78 (decided November 15, 1976): committed a crime while on parole; does not have normal entitlement to immediate parole revocation hearing even though in custody after warrant issued Albertson v. Subversive Activities Control Board, 382 U.S. 70 (decided Novemb

captcrisis
6 days ago1 min read
Today in Supreme Court History: November 13
United States v. Bormes, 568 U.S. 6 (decided November 13, 2021): dismissing lawyers’ class action re: Fair Credit Reporting Act violation of privacy (federal court filing receipts display last four digits and expiration date of lawyer’s credit card): sovereign immunity not waived Ayers v. Belmontes, 549 U.S. 7 (decided November 13, 2006): no error in judge not specifically instructing jury to consider future mitigating circumstances in sentencing (here, that defendant would l

captcrisis
Nov 121 min read
Today in Supreme Court History: November 12
Winter v. Natural Resources Defense Council, 555 U.S. 7 (decided November 12, 2008): vacating stay of antisubmarine SONAR use by Navy off California shore; strong national security interest and no showing it actually harms marine mammals (“not a close question”) Barnhart v. Thomas, 540 U.S. 20 (decided November 12, 2003): laid-off elevator operator was properly denied Social Security Disability; though suffering from heart disease, lumbar strain, etc., was still able to physi

captcrisis
Nov 111 min read
Today in Supreme Court History: November 11
Boylan v. Hot Springs Ry. Co., 132 U.S. 146 (decided November 11, 1889): passenger properly thrown off train when refusing to pay extra on return trip even though he had paid round trip fare, where ticket (which he hadn’t read) required it be stamped at departing station and he didn’t get it stamped (the language of the ticket, quoted in a footnote, is so extensive that it had to have been “fine print”) Connecticut v. Menillo, 423 U.S. 9 (decided November 11, 1975): Connectic

captcrisis
Nov 101 min read
Today in Supreme Court History: November 10
Ex Parte Crouch, 112 U.S. 178 (decided November 10, 1884): federal courts cannot via habeas vacate state court convictions except on jurisdictional grounds (gradually overruled, see Brown v. Allen, 1953) Baltimore & O.R. Co. v. Kepner, 314 U.S. 44 (decided November 10, 1941): state court cannot interfere with resident injured railroad employee’s statutorily permitted federal venue of FELA action even if inconvenient for railroad (suit brought 700 miles away in New York, where

captcrisis
Nov 91 min read
Today in Supreme Court History: November 9
Harris v. Forklift Systems, Inc., 510 U.S. 17 (decided November 9, 1993): Title VII claimant (“abusive work environment”) need not show that her psychological well-being was “seriously affected”; totality of circumstances but still must be “objectively” abusive (ALJ found supervisor made frequent gender insults, sexual innuendos, “You’re a woman, what do you know”, “We need a man as the rental manager”, “you’re a dumb ass woman”, suggested “we go to the Holiday Inn”, asked he

captcrisis
Nov 81 min read
Today in Supreme Court History: November 8
Greene v. Fisher, 565 U.S. 34 (decided November 8, 2011): violation of “clearly established federal law” required for habeas does not include law established by Court in decision announced after state appeals on facts are exhausted United States v. Olson, 546 U.S. 43 (decided November 8, 2005): Federal Tort Claims Act allows only for torts for which state law holds private parties (not governmental entities) liable, and court must determine if state law provides private law a

captcrisis
Nov 71 min read
Today in Supreme Court History: November 7
Cleveland v. United States, 531 U.S. 12 (decided November 7, 2000): video poker licenses were not “property” so as to be predicate for prosecution under mail fraud statute (defendants had obtained licenses via applications with fraudulently concealed facts) Powell v. Alabama, 287 U.S. 45 (decided November 7, 1932): in one of the earliest “incorporation” decisions, Court holds Sixth Amendment right to counsel was “incorporated” by Fourteenth Amendment and therefore binding on

captcrisis
Nov 51 min read
Today in Supreme Court History: November 6
Weeth v. New England Mortgage Security Co., 106 U.S. 605 (decided November 6, 1882): the Supreme Court used to have jurisdiction when a “certificate of division” was presented to it, where there was a disagreement between the District Judge and the Circuit Justice (from the Supreme Court); here (in a dispute over loan repayment) certificate rejected because required Court to get into fact-finding Mount Lemmon Fire District v. Guido, 139 S.Ct. 22 (decided November 6, 2018): 20

captcrisis
Nov 51 min read
Today in Supreme Court History: November 5
Buchanan v. Warley, 245 U.S. 60 (decided November 5, 1917): striking down on Due Process grounds ordinance prohibiting sale to black people of house on majority-white block (plaintiff was white man who wanted to enforce the contract of sale to a black man) (distinguished Plessy on the grounds that in that case black people had to ride in separate car, but were not denied access to the train) Burt v. Titlow, 571 U.S. 12 (decided November 5, 2013): federal court can’t disturb s

captcrisis
Nov 41 min read
Today in Supreme Court History: November 4
District of Columbia v. Eslin, 183 U.S. 62 (decided November 4, 1901): judgment by contractor against the District of Columbia’s Board of Public Works is uncollectable because filed in court which no longer had jurisdiction, even though judgment and notice of appeal were filed before statute eliminating jurisdiction was enacted (repeal statute had explicitly vacated all existing proceedings) (sounds to me like the statute violated Due Process) Stanton v. Sims, 571 U.S. 3 (dec

captcrisis
Nov 31 min read
Today in Supreme Court History: November 3
Elk v. Wilkins, 112 U.S. 94 (decided November 3, 1884): Native American born on reservation is not a citizen and therefore cannot vote even though he moved off reservation, renounced his tribal affiliation, and claimed Fourteen Amendment birthright citizenship (holding was abrogated by Indian Citizenship Act of 1924) Rose v. Arkansas State Police, 479 U.S. 1 (decided November 3, 1986): strikes down on Supremacy Clause grounds Arkansas workers’ compensation statute subtracting

captcrisis
Nov 21 min read
Today in Supreme Court History: November 2
United States v. Kirby Lumber Co., 284 U.S. 1 (decided November 2, 1931): the gain realized by company which bought up its own bonds at a lower price than issued is taxable United States v. Portale, 235 U.S. 27 (decided November 2, 1914): another opinion by Holmes, concerning conviction under a statute that someone should explain to me (currently 18 U.S. §2424): if you harbor an alien woman brought here for prostitution, you must file a statement to that effect with Immigrati

captcrisis
Nov 11 min read
Today in Supreme Court History: November 1
Graham v. Fulton County Special Purpose Grand Jury, 143 S.Ct. 397 (decided November 1, 2022): According to Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger, Sen. Lindsey Graham leaned on him after the 2020 election to discard some absentee ballots. Does the Speech and Debate Clause (art. I, §6, cl. 1) prohibit questioning of Graham about this in front of a Georgia grand jury investigating Trump’s interference with the election results? Court holds that Clause applies to Graham

captcrisis
Oct 312 min read
bottom of page